| Name |
Pos. |
Year(s) |
Team |
| John Turley |
QB |
1934 |
AP Little All-America (1st Team) |
| James Madison |
T |
1947 |
AP Little All-America (HM) |
| Albert Long |
T |
1947 |
AP Little All-America (2nd Team) |
| Dale Bruce |
E |
1951 |
AP Little All-America (1st Team) |
| Bob Hancher |
QB |
1954 |
Williamson (HM) |
| Ray Van Orden |
T |
1956 |
Methodist All-America (Coll. Div. 1st Team) |
| Jim Rogers |
HB |
1956 |
Methodist All-America (3rd Team) |
| Lynn Beach |
T |
1956 |
Methodist All-America (HM) |
| Tom Zesiger |
E |
1956 |
Williamson (3rd Team) |
| Dick DeHaven |
E-HB |
1958 |
Williamson (HM) |
| Dick DeHaven |
E-HB |
1959 |
Methodist All-America (Coll. Div. 2nd Team) |
| Doug Schmidt |
QB |
1958 |
Williamson (HM) |
| Doug Schmidt |
QB |
1958 |
Methodist All-America (Coll. Div. 1st Team) |
| Max Urick |
C-LB |
1959 |
AP Little All-America (HM) |
| Max Urick |
C-LB |
1960 |
Williamson 1st Team |
| Max Urick |
C-LB |
1960 |
Methodist All-America (Coll. Div. 1st Team) |
| Jay Farrar |
FB |
1959-60 |
Methodist All-America (Coll. Div. 2nd Team,
Coll. Div. 2nd Team) |
| Del Stumbo |
HB |
1960 |
Methodist All-America (Coll. Div. 2nd Team) |
| Steve Dutton |
DE |
1971 |
Kodak College Division (AFCA) 1st Team |
| Brian Burby |
DE |
1974 |
AP Little All-America (3rd Team) |
| Mike Wallace |
QB |
1981 |
AP Little All-America (HM) |
| Eric DiMartino |
LB |
1982-83 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III
(HM, 3rd Team) |
| Eric DiMartino |
LB |
1983 |
Kodak College Division (AFCA) 1st Team |
| Dean Hood |
DB |
1984-86 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III (HM, HM, HM) |
| Dean Hood |
DB |
1986 |
Football News Division III (1st Team) |
| Dean Cordle |
LB |
1984-85 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III (HM) |
| Bob Hill |
TE |
1984-85 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III
(3rd Team, HM) |
| John Ane |
P |
1985 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III (HM) |
| Perry Walker |
SE |
1986 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III (HM) |
| Neil Ringers |
DE |
1988-90 |
AP Little All-America
(2nd Team, 2nd Team, 1st Team) |
| Neil Ringers |
DE |
1988-90 |
Football Gazette Division III
(2nd Team, 1st Team, 1st Team) |
| Neil Ringers |
DE |
1988-89 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III (HM, HM) |
| Neil Ringers |
DE |
1990 |
Champion Division III (1st Team) |
| Kevin Sims |
FB |
1988 |
AP Little All-America (HM) |
| Kevin Sims |
FB |
1988-89 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM, HM) |
| Kevin Sims |
FB |
1988-89 |
CoSIDA/Pizza Hut Division III (HM, HM) |
| Kevin Sims |
FB |
1990 |
Champion Division III (2nd Team) |
| Jeff Court |
G |
1989-90 |
Football Gazette Division III (3rd Team, 1st Team) |
| Jeff Court |
G |
1990 |
Champion Division III (1st Team) |
| Eric Abbot |
DT |
1989, 1991 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM, HM) |
| Kirk Jackson |
LB |
1989 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM) |
| Keith Rucker |
NG |
1989, 1991 |
Football Gazette Division III
(HM, 1st Team) |
| Keith Rucker |
NG |
1990-91 |
AP Little All-America (3rd Team, 1st Team) |
| Keith Rucker |
NG |
1990-91 |
Champion Division III (HM, 3rd Team) |
| Keith Rucker |
NG |
1991 |
Kodak College Division (AFCA) (1st Team) |
| Steve Alexander |
TE |
1991-92 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM, HM) |
| Doug Dean |
LB |
1991 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM) |
| Terry Mee |
DB |
1991 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM) |
| Terry Mee |
DB |
1991 |
Champion Division III (3rd Team) |
| Kevin Ramsier |
G |
1991-92 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM, HM) |
| Kevin Ramsier |
G |
1992 |
Champion Division III (HM) |
| Kevin Ramsier |
G |
1992 |
Associated Press Little All-America (3rd Team) |
| Ryan Spicer |
DB |
1992-93 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM, HM) |
| Ryan Spicer |
DB |
1993 |
AP Little All-America (3rd Team) |
| Doug Haas |
G |
1993 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM) |
| Matt Apel |
TE |
1994 |
AP Little All-America (2nd Team) |
| Matt Apel |
TE |
1994 |
Division III SIDs All-America (HM) |
| Craig Anderson |
LB |
1994 |
Division III SIDs All-America (HM) |
| Craig Anderson |
LB |
1995-96 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (HM, 2nd Team) |
| Craig Anderson |
LB |
1995-96 |
Football Gazette Division III
(3rd Team, 1st Team) |
| Regan Fitzpatrick |
DB |
1995 |
AP Little All-America (2nd Team) |
| Regan Fitzpatrick |
DB |
1995 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (3rd Team) |
| Regan Fitzpatrick |
DB |
1995 |
Football Gazette Division III (2nd Team) |
| Ike Reid |
DE |
1998-99 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (3rd Team, 2nd Team) |
| Ike Reid |
DE |
1998-99 |
Football Gazette Division III
(3rd Team, 2nd Team) |
| Mike Fowler |
DB |
1998-99 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (3rd Team, 1st Team) |
| Mike Fowler |
DB |
1999 |
Football Gazette Division III (1st Team) |
| Mike Fowler |
DB |
1999 |
AP Little All-America (3rd Team) |
| Matt Capone |
TB |
2001 |
Football Gazette Division III (2nd Team) |
| Matt Capone |
TB |
2001 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (3rd Team) |
| Joe Kyte |
G |
2001 |
Football Gazette Division III (2nd Team) |
| Joe Kyte |
G |
2001 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (1st Team) |
| Jason Martin |
DB |
2001 |
Football Gazette Division III (3rd Team) |
| Jeff Hollway |
C |
2001 |
Hewlett-Packard Division III (SIDs)
All-America (3rd Team) |
| Jeff Hollway |
C |
2002 |
Football Gazette Division III (3rd Team) |
| Cisco Clervoix |
DT |
2005 |
D3football.com (2nd Team) |
| Cisco Clervoix |
DT |
2005 |
Football Gazette Division III (2nd Team) |
| Owen Case |
DE |
2006 |
Football Gazette Division III (HM) |
| Calvin Cagney |
TE |
2012 |
D3football.com (3rd Team) |
| Kyle Hogan |
ST |
2018 |
D3football.com (1st Team) |
| Nick Heidel |
FS |
2019 |
D3football.com (HM) |
| Shane Quin |
LB |
2020-21 |
D3football.com (2nd Team) |
